Sales Associate

Tonya Johnson

Hi y’all! I’m Tonya Johnson, your Southern real estate agent with a heart for home and hospitality.

Not only am I a Realtor, but I’ve also owned my own antiques and vintage home décor store — Myrtle Jane’s — right here in Fort Payne for the past 18 years. You could say I’ve helped decorate quite a few homes and cabins around our neck of the woods!

Born and raised in the South, I know what truly makes a house a home — it’s not just the bricks and beams, it’s the porch sittin’, sweet tea sippin’, and neighbors who wave as they pass. Whether you’re buying your first home, upgrading for a growing family, or settling into that sweet forever spot, I’m here to guide you through every step with honesty, heart, and a whole lotta hustle.

Having grown up and lived right here in Fort Payne, I bring a deep knowledge of our local market and a true passion for helping folks find their perfect place. I treat every client like family — because in the South, that’s just how we do it.

Let’s find your dream home, y’all — I’d be honored to help you make the move!

Testimonials

Kind & Helpful

I just wanted to take a moment and say thank you. You went out of your way to be kind and helpful. Just know how much your efforts are appreciated.

Professional

Awesome experience. Very professional and polite. We love our new home!

Hard Workers!

An agent of Ole Heritage Real Estate was able to get my 1912 farmhouse sold. It was a struggle, but she and her Broker Tina had wisdom and abilities and got it done. Not only did I sell my house through them but bought another. I’m ecstatic after all was said and done. Call these ladies, they’ll take care of your home buying/selling needs. Thank you, ladies, for facing the challenges and getting it done.

Success Story

The Ole Heritage team was fantastic! We listed and sold our family home with them. They made the process easy to understand and as stress-free as possible.

Relocating Worry-free

We relocated from out of state, so trying to see houses only on the weekends was a challenge on our end. Donna was extremely patient, kind & hard working! I would trust her, her judgment & her experience time & time again! Hopefully we wont need her again as she found us our forever home! But happily recommend Donna to anyone needing to buy or sell a home. Donna was & is amazing!!!!

Return Customers

This is our 2nd time using Donna Willingham at Ole Heritage Realty to sell or buy a property. She truly goes above and beyond to get you to closing or help with anything in-between. It’s really refreshing to have someone go to bat for you and show honesty and kindness. We would refer Donna Willingham and Ole Heritage Realty to anyone who wants proper representation through real estate transactions. These ladies know what they are doing!